We need evidence-based decision making
by Wim Laven
753 words
Imagine for a moment that political discussions can assume the same evidence-based knowledge as active components in decision making as treatment pathways do when responding to illness and disease. The impact of care is studied out of a need for protecting and preserving quality of life. Politics should also serve these same ends, but, indeed, politics carries a burden healthcare does not: different values. Forgetting that there are legitimate differences in values—like I prioritize equality over security or others prioritize fiscal responsibility over freedom--let’s briefly return to the idea of truth as a foundation for politics and policy.
Ignorance presents a challenge to truth. After all, there is no way to accommodate good decision making when there are serious gaps in information. Medical professionals make diagnostic tests in order to figure out what’s wrong, the same as mechanics do when the check engine light comes on in your car. Drinking water, for example, will help alleviate a headache caused by dehydration but is unlikely to help much for a headache caused by meningitis.
The (then) War Department, published Training Manual No. 2000-25, inWashington, D.C., November 30, 1928. It provides instruction on being a citizen, and describes and defines key terms. “These precise and scholarly definitions of a Democracy and a Republic were carefully considered as a proper guide for U.S. soldiers and U.S. citizens by the Chief of Staff of the United States Army.” What people should, or should not do, has always been a source of conflict, but “a well informed public” is enumerated in most democratic proscriptions. After all, the power is in the hands of the people and information is prerequisite to good decision making. The current political crisis in the United States could actually be resolved with evidence-based decision making.
Do not take my word for it, read the “Report on the Investigation into Russian Interference in the 2016 Presidential Election” (in short: “Mueller Report”) yourself. Once you have read it you will likely have the same conclusion that everyone (except William Barr, but virtually literally everyone else) has. An abbreviated list of the evidence:
1) The Russians, on order from Russian President Vladimir Putin, attempted to help Trump and hurt Clinton, (vol. 1, pp. 4-5, 35).
2) The Trump campaign was quite willing to accept their help (vol. 1, pp. 5-7).
3) Numerous suspicious connections between Russians and the Trump campaign (vol. 1, pp. 8-10).
4) Russia hacked the accounts of multiple people involved in the Clinton campaign and illegally dumped that material, to the Trump campaign’s benefit (vol. 1, pp. 36-50).
5) Russia also made cyber attacks on U.S. state and local entities, state boards of elections, secretaries of state, and county governments including their employees (vol. 1, pp. 50-51).
6) Mueller decided not to charge the president for obstruction, because of a Justice Department policy (vol. 2, pp. 1-2, 8).
7) Obstruction of justice can be charged when there is no underlying crime. (vol. 2, pp. 9-12, 157).
8) The president, as head of the Executive Branch, is not above obstruction laws (vol. 2, pp. 168-169, 180).
9) The evidence for several instances of potential obstruction (there were 11 total) were strong enough to bring charges, but refer to point 4 (vol. 2, pp. 87-90, 97-98, 111-113, 118-120).
10) President Trump was not exonerated regarding obstruction of justice (vol. 2, pp. 8, 182).
Or, read the executive summaries provided with the report, volume 1 (pp. 4-10) and volume 2 (pp. 1-8) provide the reader with the important conclusions from an assessment of the evidence.
If, as a country, we do not seriously push back against dishonest politicians and the politics of corruption, then we are responsible for the ugly outcomes. Walter Cronkite said, “Freedom is a package deal… with it comes responsibilities and consequences.” I believe we have moved past the point of debate; the facts are crystal clear as is the next step. But we have not moved at all; we are living in the gross injustice of dishonesty—we are failed by citizens ignoring their patriotic responsibilities to inform themselves and respond to the undeniable corruption and we are more supremely punished by the death of democracy. Political thieves are getting away with their immoral and illegitimate inaction by claiming all the power, even though the numb and fatigued public could seize it legitimately. Reclaim the urgency and higher ground by addressing the ignorance and dishonesty of our times—read and react to the Mueller Report—or you will be sorry.
~~~~~~~~
Wim Laven, Ph.D., syndicated by PeaceVoice, teaches courses in political science and conflict resolution.
================
EXPLAINING ADHD TO CHILDREN
Your Brain Is a Ferrari! (with Bicycle Brakes)
"In my 30-plus years, I have learned that the moment of delivering the ADHD diagnosis ranks among the most crucial. It can determine the arc of a person’s life." | Read more from Dr. Ned Hallowell on explaining ADHD with positivity →
Puberty Is Coming... You've Been Warned
"My daughter's tween moods are far more hyperactive than my son’s body ever was!"
Read more →
Why Your Child Refuses Help
A compelling new model defines six stages of change, starting with "I can't do this!" Use it to increase the chance that your child accepts interventions.
Read more →
Start your subscription to ADDitude magazine in print and digital format with a free issue and free instant access to the ADHD Medication and Treatment eBook!
"My Stubborn ADD Epiphany"
"'Not my child' was my refrain for 16 years. By denying any problems or a need for medication, we made him feel responsible (even guilty) for his struggles."
Read more →
Deputy Secretary Censky in Minnesota Monday and Tuesday
(Washington, D.C., June 14, 2019) – U.S. Deputy Secretary of Agriculture Stephen Censky will be in Minnesota on MONDAY, June 17th and Tuesday, June 18th for a series of events on rural health and economic development.
Monday, June 17th
Deputy Secretary Censky to Tour Community Memorial Hospital with Deputy Secretary of Health and Human Services Eric Hargan and Congressman Pete Stauber (MN-08)
WHAT: Deputy Secretary Censky, HHS Deputy Secretary Hargan, and Congressman Stauber will tour the Community Memorial Hospital in Cloquet, MN and will meet with hospital leadership Rick Breuer (CEO) and Brad Anderson (CFO). Press are invited to join and report on the hospital tour. The meeting with hospital staff will be closed-press. Following the event, Deputy Secretary Censky will hold a media availability.
WHEN: MONDAY, June 17th beginning at 11:00am CT.
WHERE: Community Memorial Hospital, 512 Skyline Blvd, Cloquet, Minnesota 55720
Deputy Secretary Censky to Participate in Health Roundtable Discussion with HHS Deputy Secretary Hargan and Congressman Stauber
WHAT: Deputy Secretary Censky will participate in a roundtable discussion on regional agriculture and healthcare issues with HHS Deputy Secretary Hargan, Congressman Stauber, and local elected and economic development officials.
WHEN: MONDAY, June 17th beginning at 2:00pm CT.
WHERE: Kitchi Gammi Club, 831 E Superior St, Duluth, Minnesota 55802
Deputy Secretary Censky to Speak at Minnesota Rural Health Conference with HHS Deputy Secretary Hargan
WHAT: Deputy Secretary Steve Censky will attend the Minnesota Rural Health Conference with Deputy Secretary Eric Hargan. Deputy Secretary Censky and Deputy Secretary Hargan will participate in a panel discussion, followed by a Q&A. Following the event, Deputy Secretary Censky will participate in a media availability.
WHEN: MONDAY, June 17th beginning at 3:15pm CT.
WHERE: 350 Harbor Dr, Duluth, Minnesota 55802
Tuesday, June 18th
Deputy Secretary Censky to Participate in Roundtable Discussion
WHAT: Deputy Secretary Steve Censky will participate in a roundtable discussion with Minnesota agriculture industry leaders. Following the event, Deputy Secretary Censky will participate in a media availability.
WHEN: TUESDAY, June 18th beginning at 2:00pm CT.
WHERE: 400 Robert St N, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101
"Why Is My Loving Child So Distant in Public?"
Q: "'Drop me at the corner... don’t talk to my friends!' At home, however, my son is very affectionate. Why does he do this??"
Read the answer →
FREE WEBINAR ON JUNE 18
Vaping & Teens with ADHD
Learn how to discuss this dangerous habit with your teen, plus prevention and treatment advice. Register now »
FREE WEBINAR ON JULY 8
Mindfulness for Children
Learn why kids with ADHD have trouble regulating their emotions, and exercises designed to calm an unsettled child.
+ More ADHD Parenting Webinars - Register now to save your place!
JUL. 23: How to Optimize Stimulant Treatment for Children and Adults
AUG. 1: A Guide to the ADHD Medication Formulations and Delivery Options
AUG. 13: Teaching Executive Functions to Children with ADHD
AUG. 29: Reset Your Schedule for School: A Calmer, Happier, Easier Routine
SEPT. 5: Behavioral Parent Training: The Best Kind of Discipline
USDA Radio Newsline
Friday, June 14th Stories:
